Lear's
Shadow

Produced by Douglas Ord

Left: From A Schizo-Philosopher's Colouring Book

"... un individu acquiert un véritable nom propre, à l’issue du plus sévère exercise de dépersonnalisation, quand il s’ouvre aux multiplicités qui le traversent de part en part, aux intensités qui le parcourent."

           -- Gilles Deleuze, 
               "Lettre à un critique sévère" (1973)

February, 2016

Lear's Shadow remains at the level of technology that was available at its beginning in May, 2000.  This level perhaps deserves rethinking.  For the time being, the site will continue at this address and in the current format. 

The Lear's Shadow e-book The strangeness of Columbine, an interpretation, as published in 2012, has been made available free of charge here in both PDF and EPUB formats.  This was done without consultation or permission, by someone who has sought to provide access to as much Columbine-related material as possible.  This seems a worthy goal, so Lear's Shadow makes no objection.  Anyone who wants, out of courtesy to the labour and expense that went into the e-book's development, to pay the asked price of $5.99, can go to the Amazon Kindle site, or the iBookstore site, or to some other, more familiar platform where it is available.  This will be appreciated.  But if the perceived choice is between paying for the e-book, and not reading it or even venturing into it, then please: by all means go ahead and download it. 

A couple of points to clarify, however:

First: whoever has made the files available states at the linked page, "Much of this book was originally posted on Lear’s Shadow’s website here: http://home.eol.ca/~dord/."  In fact, none of what's in The strangeness of Columbine was "originally posted" at this website.  As has for some time been stated below, on the part of this page to do with the e-book:

The strangeness of Columbine, an interpretation, e-published in January, 2012, does not duplicate Lear's Shadow as a website. What it does do, via new material including photographs, is further develop some of the themes introduced here.
"The themes introduced here" are primarily via five texts that date from the period 1999-2001, and that in the site's early years were grouped, for a time with some others, under the heading "An Inquiry into Columbine's Iconic Profile in Five Levels."

So as to make things simple, here are the links to these five pages as they exist in February, 2016, with associated images.  There was a period during which these texts and images were withdrawn from circulation.  While down, however, they were retrieved anonymously from the internet archive, re-assembled, and made available on an aggregate site.  And while they were down, too, rumour circulated that Lear's Shadow had made the claim that Calvin and Hobbes "caused Columbine." Lear's Shadow never claimed anything of the sort, and the texts were restored in part so that what they actually say could be available:

 

FROM ABSOLUTE
OTHER TO 
ERIC AND DYLAN

CALVIN AND ERIC,
DYLAN AND HOBBES I

CALVIN AND ERIC,
DYLAN AND HOBBES II

CALVIN AND ERIC,
DYLAN AND HOBBES III

KURTZ'S CHILDREN

The strangeness of Columbine: an interpretation is where this sequence goes after "Kurtz's Children."   

So for those who do opt to download the e-book, please be clear: what you will find in it does not duplicate what is at the above pages.  It is a different kind of mapping.  The e-book is introduced directly below, via the image that appears on its cover. 

Secondly: whoever made the PDF/EPUB files available raises the question of authorship of "Just A Day," as an unsigned, single-page text found among Eric Harris's papers, and reprinted at page 870 in the 900-page Jefferson County Sheriff's Office document release of July 6, 2006 (which -- just to mention a third relevant six across this date -- happened to be then-President George W. Bush's 60th birthday). 

Some dice throw.

In the e-book, "Just A Day" is attributed to Eric Harris.  But a case has also been made, since the e-book's publication, for its ascription to Dylan Klebold, mainly on account of the repeated presence in the text of ampersands and of the word "halcyon."  It even seems possible, as someone on a Columbine forum once suggested, that it was written by both of them.

The e-book, however, makes a case, that pre-dates awareness that a case might need to be made, that "Just A Day" bears qualities of relation to multiple aspects of Eric Harris's background and sensibility.  By way of stylistic and tonal comparison, the oddly titled personal essay "Pioners," at page 858 in the document release is suggested.  The presence of ampersands in "Just A Day" renders probable, but not certain, Dylan Klebold's involvement.  Worth noting, perhaps, is that Eric Harris could be not so much an imitator, as a tryer-on, a keeper or discarder, an inhabiter: in the way, for example, he appropriated and inhabited three songs by KMFDM on his website, keeping only parts of them, or the way he came to inhabit the game Doom.  It is not inconceivable that he "tried on" Dylan's relationship to ampersands, or just tried on ampersands.   And while the word "halcyon" certainly figures in Dylan's texts, there is also a memorable trance song called "Halcyon" by one of Eric Harris's stated favourite bands, Orbital.  Simply considering "Just A Day" in conjunction with this song might be helpful.

It can be noted also that an effort was made, through Brooks Brown, to ascertain which family owned "a 1974 Dodge Ram," as described in "Just A Day."  He could not recall that either had owned one.  Perhaps this detail was fictional.

As for the text of The strangeness of Columbine, an interpretation: it can be described in retrospect as a process of extracting sense not from relations of cause and effect, but via the other two "principles of association of ideas" named by David Hume in A Treatise of Human Nature published in 1739: "resemblance" and "contiguity of time or place." These are not explicitly referred to in the e-book, but will be elaborated on in the text "A short account of some theory that informs Lear's Shadow," that is in development.  The first person pronoun is deployed, in Part Three of the e-book especially, as what can be called, in philosophical terms, a phenomenological device, toward affirming particularity of perspective rather than claiming an omniscient overview.

Of great help in clarifying these matters has been sustained study of the French philosopher Gilles Deleuze (1925-1995), that was enabled especially through development of an Interdisciplinary Humanities Master's thesis called Differenciations of "enfant" / "child" in the Achievement of Gilles Deleuze.  This is available in its entirety online.  Clarification has also been assisted by a year of PhD study that made for close readings in particular of Deleuze on Francis Bacon (Logique de la sensation, 1981) and David Hume (Empirisme et subjectivité, 1953).

The quotation credited above to Deleuze reads in English (respecting his use of the third person singular "il"): 

"... an individual acquires a true proper name as the issue of a most severe exercise in depersonalization, when he opens himself to the multiplicities that traverse him through and through, to the intensities that cut across him."
Such it has been, perhaps, with Lear's Shadow and Columbine, in its multiplicities and intensities.
-----


Quick links:

Early Lear's Shadow Columbine material (2000-2001)

The strangeness of Columbine, an interpretation (2012 e-book)

Mapping temporal layers of theatricalized massacre in the USA 1864/1999/2012 and 1637/2012 (2014)
 

stereopticon (2001)

Of Sky Signs, Avalanches, and the Synchronity Fuse (2003, with updates)

Not just "the average civilian casualty episode" (2003)

Deliverance Comes to Iraq (2004)

Earlier books 

In active development:

A short account of some theory that informs Lear's Shadow

Of Sky Signs, Avalanches, and the Synchronicity Fuse (A Reassessment)

And:

A 262-page labyrinthine entity, in story form.

In e-book format because this was easiest.

Available on various platforms for $4.99. 

The amazon.com page is here, and is mentioned only because it's easiest also.


 
The strangeness of Columbine, an interpretation
At left is the cover of the Lear's Shadow e-book published in January, 2012.  It presents, as surface, a slice of space-time as a rectangle: a kind of map.

Spatially, this rectangle shows central and eastern Colorado, via adaptation of a NASA satellite image  made by the Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS), aboard the satellite Terra.  Distance above the Earth's surface was 440 miles / 700 kilometers.  The NASA image has been cropped and rotated.  Unlike with most maps, west is up The site of Columbine High School is indicated by a white dot.

Temporally, the rectangle maps October 26, 2001, as the date when MODIS recorded the image.

Just a day.

Within whose twenty four hour time frame also, in Washington DC: 1) President George W. Bush signed the USA-PATRIOT Act into law, increasing U.S. Government surveillance by orders of magnitude; and 2) the Pentagon awarded the military contract, the biggest in U.S. history, to Lockheed Martin Corporation for the F-35 Joint Strike Fighter. 

Lockheed Martin also built the Atlas rocket that carried Terra-MODIS into Earth orbit, thus enabling the image at left. 

Indeed, assembly of this very rocket took place at Lockheed Martin Space Systems Astronautics Operations on West Deer Creek Canyon Road in Littleton, Colorado.

This being the road along which Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold broke into an unoccupied white van on January 30, 1998, setting in motion their involvement with the juvenile justice system.  The Lockheed Martin facility can be seen as a long white edifice, alone amid the foothills scrubland, from the big red rock above and behind the house where Dylan Klebold grew up.

Perhaps it is correct to assert, as David Hume did, that inference can be drawn only from cause and effect, most convincingly through repeatable experiment, and not from "Resemblance" or "Contiguity of time or place", as principles of association of ideas.

But if one cannot infer, one can still marvel.

The adaptation of the NASA photograph is repeated at right, without lettering.  It shows central and eastern Colorado  not only at an instant of October 26, 2001, but also as never before seen by human eyes.  It is used, as per the terms on NASA's website, with acknowledgment that NASA owns it, and credit to Jacques Descloitres, MODIS Land Rapid Response Team.

The NASA version of the image is here

The NASA caption  reads:   “An early season snowfall accents the Rocky Mountains through western and central Colorado.”

Try considering this image as you might a Rorschach ink blot, but without the symmetries, on gigantic scale, and via a different filter from the psychological, in terms of singular patterns that are nevertheless clearly the product of chance and natural forces at a precise moment.

And try also referencing what Gilles Deleuze might call a virtual aboriginal perspective, paradoxically via a physical perspective never available to "an aboriginal":

How many animal spirit-figures in the mountains?


The strangeness of Columbine, an interpretation, e-published in January, 2012, does not duplicate Lear's Shadow as a website. What it does do, via new material including photographs, is further develop  some of the themes introduced here.

Because of continued interest in early Lear's Shadow Columbine texts,  and so that rumours do not circulate as to what they might say, as happened before when they were taken down, links to some of them are at the bottom of this page.

The strangeness of Columbine, an interpretation is $5.99 via Amazon Kindle, the iBookstore, Sony, Kobo, and Barnes & Noble.  The preface and first chapter can be read at the Amazon Kindle site, or at the iBookstore site.  Total length is 335 pages, with 33 images.

Lear's Shadow is not and never has been a for- profit enterprise.  The $5.99 cover price is just an attempt -- likely for various reasons ludicrous -- to recover even a portion of expenses.

Dylan Klebold's house, 
with Fountain Formation rocks,
January 23, 2001

Mapping temporal layers of theatricalized massacre in the USA
1864/1999/2012 and 1637/2012

These strange young males make for disturbing reading.  But such correlations among and between temporal plateaux, as are suggested in the sequencing of dates, and in terms of common elements in the events themselves, exist.  And in doing so, they make, to quote Deleuze of Logique du sens (1969), for "an ensemble of non-causal correspondences, forming a system of echoes, of reprises, and of resonances, a system of signs, in brief, an expressive quasi-causality, not at all a necessitating causality."    This text is an experiment in how to read in these terms.


 
September 2012 restorations
to Lear's Shadow

Two binocular chapters of the same story: an empire sent hurtling into precipitous decline, after plunging over a precipice.

 


stereopticon

Named site of the week for the 6-month anniversary of September 11 2001 by the Guerrilla News Network, which called it “one of the most thought-provoking and profound examinations of the events and images of 9-11, its precedents and aftermath, we have seen.”


One of the most hubristic documents in human history, The National Security Strategy of the United States of America, published by the Bush White House in September, 2002, begins: 

"The great struggles of the twentieth century between liberty and totalitarianism ended with a decisive victory for the forces of freedom—and a single sustainable model for national success: freedom, democracy, and free enterprise. " 

Seven months later, in March, 2003, the United States of America invaded Iraq. 
 


Not just "the average civilian casualty episode"

On September 2, 2012, former Archbishop Desmond Tutu of South Africa called for former President George W. Bush of the United States and former Prime Minister Tony Blair of Great Britain to be tried for war crimes on account of their involvement in the non-U.N. sanctioned invasion of Iraq in March, 2003.  As a reminder of just one aspect of that invasion, and of its media atmospherics, here is "Not just 'the average civilian casualty episode,'" that appeared at Lear's Shadow in April-May, 2003.



 
 

Binocularity #3 

Deliverance
Comes to Iraq

May 2004


 
Earlier books by Douglas Ord
 
Tommy's Farm

Novel, 204 pages, The Mercury Press, Toronto, Canada, 1998

"Ord’s strange and wonderful novel is going on my shelf between two other works of philosophical fiction: Samuel Beckett’s Watt, that work of great formal brilliance and indeterminable purport (to quote Beckett himself), based on Cartesian logic, and Raymond Queneau’s The Bark Tree, a hilarious French new wave novel, also inspired by Descartes. Going right inside a character’s head, as Ord does here, is one of the great delights of the novel form."

                                                        -- Mark Frutkin, The Globe and Mail

Oscar and Jeannie

Novel, 208 pages, The Mercury Press, Toronto, Canada, 1999

"Ord uses [Oscar’s] losses to examine the crux of humanity.  In Oscar’s case, though, his humanity is obscured by his derailment from anything resembling a normal life.   Therein lies Ord’s genius: He makes us see Oscar as a man worthy of consideration even though he has made some huge mistakes, and he has lost all the trappings of modern society... Ord is a highly sophisticated writer dealing with profound issues."

                                            --  Candace Fertile, The Globe and Mail
 


Navigating without a Compass

Essays on contemporary art, 176 pages, Oberon Press, Ottawa, Canada, 2000

"The title is a metaphor for art writing and its battle with preconceptions. Canadian art writing also has the added hurdle of negotiating a general cultural intolerance towards most things avant-garde. Ord finds his way easily, however, with essays that insist on the significance of contemporary art to the well being of our cautious public domain."

                                                             – Canadian Art

 

The National Gallery 
of Canada, Ideas Art 
Architecture

Critical history / institutional biography, 496 pages, McGill-Queen's University Press, Montreal, Canada, 2003

"Douglas Ord’s book constitutes a major contribution to the field of museum studies in Canada, and a landmark in publishing on the topic... [His] integration of theory with practice makes this the first book of its kind... Here is a book with the potential of changing Canadian art history forever and becoming one of a handful of essential documents in the field."

         – Reesa Greenberg (peer reviewer), Concordia University, 
            author of Thinking About Exhibitions

"A brilliant piece of research and analysis, overwhelming in its scholarship, insightful in its interpretation."

– Donald Kuspit, State University of New York at Stony Brook, 
   author of The Cult  of the Avant Garde Artist
 

About Lear's Shadow

An experiment in the reading of events and patterns, whose title comes from William Shakespeare's King Lear, Act I Scene 4, when the King is slipping into madness:

Lear: Who is it that can tell 
          me who I am? 
The Fool: Lear's shadow.
Drawing at right from 
A Schizo-Philosopher's Coloring Book

Comments or inquiries can be sent to dord@eol.ca.

More in The strangeness of Columbine, an interpretation.

Five Lear's Shadow Columbine texts that date from 2000-2001, and the initial Inquiry into Columbine's Iconic Profile in Multiple Levels (a transitional reading, in utmost seriousness, of Columbine through Calvin and Hobbes, and of Calvin and Hobbes though Columbine).

 

FROM ABSOLUTE
OTHER TO ERIC AND
DYLAN

CALVIN AND ERIC,
DYLAN AND HOBBES I

CALVIN AND ERIC,
DYLAN AND HOBBES II

CALVIN AND ERIC,
DYLAN AND HOBBES III

KURTZ'S CHILDREN